Skip to content
Lex Pundit
Knowledge

Where the law stands, and how it got there.

A curated map of Canadian legal doctrine. Each entry sets out the current position, the governing authority, and the line of cases and statutes that shaped it — reviewed and dated, so you can trust it's current.

SettledChanged
Administrative · Recently changed

The standard of review on judicial review

A court reviewing an administrative decision presumptively applies a reasonableness standard, reserving correctness for defined categories.

Governing authority

Canada (MCI) v Vavilov2019 SCC 65

Vavilov is the current framework, replacing the contextual analysis set out in Dunsmuir.

How it got there
1979CUPE v NB Liquor[1979] 2 SCR 227

Courts begin to defer to a tribunal's reasonable reading of its own statute.

2008Dunsmuir v New Brunswick2008 SCC 9

The standards collapse to two — correctness and reasonableness.

2019Vavilov2019 SCC 65

A presumption of reasonableness is set, with defined correctness categories.